Practical answers for tenants and owners across Greater Montreal.
- What is a good MRB and cap rate for a plex in Quebec?
- In Greater Montreal, an MRB (price ÷ gross rents) at or below 15 is excellent, 15–18 is acceptable, and above 20 is hard to make work. A realistic cap rate of 5% or more is healthy; 4–5% is borderline and worth negotiating; below 4% rarely cashflows at current mortgage rates. The tool computes both a declared cap rate (your numbers) and a realistic cap rate (industry-norm expenses) so you can see how optimistic the seller's pro-forma is.
- Which holding structure makes the most sense for a duplex or triplex?
- For most small plex investors, holding personally (solo or as a couple) wins on after-tax IRR because corporate passive-income tax in Quebec is around 50.17% gross and only partially refunded through RDTOH when a dividend is paid. Incorporation starts to pay off above ~6 doors or when the investor's marginal rate is at the top bracket and dividends can be deferred. The comparison table makes the trade-off explicit, including setup and annual costs.
- What is the difference between indivision and a married couple holding?
- A married couple owning under partnership of acquests (régime légal since 1970) splits the income and the property economically — and the family patrimony protects the principal residence side of the deal at separation. Indivision is a contract between unrelated co-owners (or common-law partners) and requires a written agreement covering buy-out rights, vote thresholds and exit. The tool models both with similar income splits, but flags the legal documentation gap.
- What does the BUY / NEGOTIATE / AVOID verdict look at?
- Four criteria, worst wins: (1) realistic cap rate, (2) year-1 cashflow after debt service, (3) 10-year after-tax IRR, and (4) spread vs the best passive benchmark (indexed ETF, balanced 60/40, REIT). A plex that returns 6% IRR when an indexed portfolio returns 6.5% with zero management is not a good investment, even if cashflow is positive. The verdict surfaces the binding constraint so you know what to renegotiate.
- What are the stress tests for?
- They show what the deal looks like under realistic adverse scenarios: rate up 1% or 2% at renewal, vacancy at 10% (one unit empty in a triplex), a $25k surprise CapEx, three years of rent stagnation under TAL, and a 15% market drop on the exit. If year-1 cashflow stays above -$500/month and 10-year IRR stays positive in 4 of 6 scenarios, the structure is robust. If half the scenarios kill the deal, the price is wrong.
- Are the tax calculations accurate enough to act on?
- They are directional, not prescriptive. The tool uses Quebec 2026 marginal tax tables, the integrated corporate-passive rate (gross 50.17% less RDTOH refund 30.67%), and a 50% capital-gain inclusion. It does not model TOSI, income attribution between common-law partners, partnership rules, alternative minimum tax, or specific reserves. Before closing, validate the optimal structure with a CPA or tax lawyer — the tool's job is to rule out clearly bad structures and prep the conversation.
- What CapEx flags does the tool detect?
- Based on year built and the age of major components you provide: knob-and-tube wiring (pre-1950), aluminum wiring (1960–1980), Kitec plumbing failure (1995–2007), asbestos and lead paint (pre-1990), roof replacement (>20 years shingle, >25 years membrane), and windows over 25 years old. Each flag includes a typical cost in 2026 dollars. None of these replace a building inspection — they are red flags to budget for and negotiate against.
- How does the plex compare to passive investing?
- The tool compares the 10-year after-tax IRR of the plex against three passive benchmarks: an indexed ETF portfolio (≈6.5% nominal), a 60/40 balanced portfolio (≈5.5%) and a Canadian REIT index (≈7%). A plex needs to beat the best passive benchmark by at least 2% to compensate for management time, tenant risk and illiquidity. If the spread is negative or under 2%, consider whether your time is better spent elsewhere.